The Midnight Magistrate appears as a towering figure draped in flowing judicial robes woven from spliced film strips that constantly play scenes from classic exploitation cinema. It wields a supernatural gavel that thunders with iconic horror movie sound effects, and carries ethereal scales that weigh the authenticity of each player's archetype embodiment. The entity radiates an aura of midnight darkness punctuated by the flickering glow of drive-in movie screens.

The Midnight Magistrate presides over the Horror Hall of Fame's authenticity trials, serving as the ultimate arbiter who determines whether players have truly embraced their chosen horror archetypes. Its verdicts echo across all grindhouse venues, ensuring that the sacred standards of B-movie cinema are upheld throughout the entire series.